I LOVE using my Nook, phone and iPad to read e-books
voraciously, anywhere, anytime. During my undergrad, this was especially
helpful, because I was already carrying a lot of books with me for school, and
e-books saved me time and backache! Having adopted reading them early on and
having dived right in, I find the ease which they offer a huge appeal factor,
and don’t find them intimidating! I love that I can download a new book at 2
a.m. because I just finished the one before it in a series and I must know what
happens next. I love that I can change the font, the color, the backlight, etc.
Changing these factors to suit my reading conditions at that moment, allows me
to read with more ease and to comfortably and quickly get through books.
However, since beginning work at the library, I have rediscovered my love for
physical books. After my e-book sojourn, returning to books has reminded me how
much I love the ability to smell a book, to turn its pages, and to feel its
physical presence in my hands. Although they can be less convenient, and
sometimes that is really important to me, they provide some appeal that e-books
never will. Accordingly, I don’t see myself ever reading one type exclusively,
but rather continuing to vacillate between the two formats as needed, and I
love living in an age where I have so many options.
However, I have seen a new perspective of e-books now that I
work with the public. I have seen how intimidating they can be to readers who
have never ventured away from paper. I have seen how defeating it can be when
technological issues get in the way of people reading a book they have been
anticipating. And I have witnessed how sometimes e-books aren’t quite as
capable as providing an escape to the reader, because the screen causes
headaches, the battery dies, it’s too easy to get distracted by an app, and so
on and so forth. Taking these new considerations into mind, as well as my own
experiences, I try to remember both sides when working with patrons. Something
that I am really proud of is that my library hosts an open drop in every week
where we encourage our patrons to bring their e-readers so that we can show
them how to manipulate the settings to create the ultimate appeal for
themselves.
I have far less experience using audio books. The single
audio book that I have ever listened to recreationally was a poor experience.
The format through Audible wasn’t friendly to going back and forth between the
e-book and the audio book, as I was doing. The author’s voice had a cadence and
tone that I found to be more distracting than enjoyable, and I felt that the
characterization was poorly done. The pacing was also too slow for me. The
story was a fast-paced mystery that was building in suspense but the narrator would
drag out certain sections unnecessarily. Before this section I wouldn’t have
felt comfortable doing a reader’s advisory interview for audio books with my
limited, and poor experience, but they are very popular at my library so now I
feel like I have a better understanding of the appeal and how to help!
Thank you for your post. In addition to the other appeal factors you listed for eBooks, you talked about access. Access to eBooks can happen anywhere and anytime as long as there is Internet access. I like being able to access a library book when the library is closed. It feels like a library without borders.
ReplyDeleteIn addition to the appeal of physical books, I would also add the appeal of permanence. A paper book is not dependent upon software and its updates, battery life, or whether or not the publisher is still in business. Books may be bulky but they can last a very long time.
That's a good point about internet access Jeff! Although I love the ease of my eBooks, I have on many occasions forgot to load up before being in a situation where I wouldn't have wifi. I also love your quote about a library without borders, that is perfect!
ReplyDeleteThat's a great point about permanence and the points you mentioned. I actually had someone comment to me that they feel like eBooks are more of a hassle because they can die, or be removed from your device because of publisher problems, and that they would just rather have a solid book that they know they can read anytime, without technical difficulties.